Assassin's Creed Brotherhood vs Assassin's Creed III
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Assassin's Creed Brotherhood continues Ezio Auditore's saga, letting players command a network of assassins across a richly detailed Rome. The game blends stealth, parkour, and historical intrigue with a robust multiplayer experience. Set in 1500s Italy, the title introduces new mechanics like assassin recruitment, synchronized attacks, and an expanded open world that encourages exploration and strategic combat. Fans of the series will appreciate the deep narrative and refined combat system.
Set in the turbulent era of the American Revolution, Assassin's Creed III follows Connor Kenway as he fights for freedom and uncovers a secret war between Assassins and Templars. The game blends historical events with a richly detailed open world, allowing players to explore colonial cities, frontier wilderness, and iconic battles. With a seamless mix of stealth, combat, and naval warfare, players can engage in land missions, sea battles, and multiplayer skirmishes, all while experiencing a deep narrative that intertwines personal drama with historic milestones.
- Rich, detailed recreation of Renaissance Rome
- Deep assassin recruitment and management system
- Robust multiplayer with varied modes
- Improved combat and stealth mechanics
- Stunning period‑accurate environments
- Deep, story‑driven campaign
- Innovative naval combat system
- Robust multiplayer options
- Occasional frame‑rate drops on older hardware
- Multiplayer matchmaking can be slow
- Some side missions feel repetitive
- Occasional frame‑rate drops on older hardware
- Repetitive side‑mission design
- Stealth mechanics can feel unforgiving
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
View all →
Ezio's final journey blends history, stealth, and breathtaking Istanbul vistas
Experience the American Revolution through the eyes of a legendary Assassin
Alternatives to Assassin's Creed III
View all →Ezio's final journey blends history, stealth, and breathtaking Istanbul vistas
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataAssassin's Creed Brotherhood is the slightly higher-rated, safer default for players seeking management mechanics in Renaissance Rome, while Assassin's Creed III trades that for frontier exploration and naval combat in 18th-century America.
Key differences
- •Setting and Map: Brotherhood is set in Renaissance Rome featuring landmarks like the Colosseum, whereas AC3 is set in 18th-century America spanning Boston streets and the Appalachian frontier with a dynamic weather and day-night cycle.
- •Unique Mechanics: Brotherhood introduces recruiting and managing up to 30 assassins and a synchronized attack mechanic; AC3 introduces period-accurate naval combat on the Hudson River.
- •Pricing: AC3 has a listed one-time paid price ($59.99 MSRP), while Brotherhood requires you to 'Contact for Pricing' though its MSRP is also listed at $59.99.
- •Release Date: Brotherhood released on 2010-11-16 with a critic score of 83/100, while AC3 released later on 2012-10-30 with a critic score of 81/100.
Gameplay & fun factor
Brotherhood edges out with an 83 critic score and features like assassin recruitment and refined counter-attacks, compared to AC3's 81 score.
Platform availability
Not specified for either product beyond developer and publisher details.
Price & value
AC3 is a paid one-time purchase with a listed MSRP of $59.99, whereas Brotherhood requires contacting for pricing.
Multiplayer / co-op
Both offer single-player and multiplayer modes supporting cooperative and competitive play (Brotherhood supports up to four players).
Content & replayability
Both feature deep single-player campaigns, crafting systems, and multiplayer options, though both share cons of repetitive side-mission design.
Difficulty & accessibility
Both share the same ESRB M and PEGI 18 age ratings and suffer from occasional frame-rate drops on older hardware.
Graphics & performance
Both share the same developer and publisher, and both note occasional frame-rate drops on older hardware as a con.
Choose Assassin's Creed Brotherhood if…
Players who want to manage a guild of assassins in Renaissance Rome with improved combat mechanics.
Choose Assassin's Creed III if…
Players who want naval combat, frontier exploration, and a story set during the American Revolution.
Common questions
How much do these games cost?
Assassin's Creed III is a paid one-time purchase with an MSRP of $59.99, while Brotherhood requires you to contact for pricing (though its MSRP is also listed at $59.99).
Which game has better critic reviews?
Assassin's Creed Brotherhood has a slightly higher critic score of 83/100, compared to Assassin's Creed III's score of 81/100.
Do both games feature multiplayer?
Yes, both games include single-player and multiplayer modes featuring cooperative and competitive options.